Living in NYC, I was able watch and follow Toney when he was a Giants' first round pick.
There were injuries, the Giants lacked talent and the coaches were constantly changing. However, Toney struck me as much more than an immature headcase or slow-learner. I got the impression early-on that this was a gifted athlete who was simply NOT interested in playing football. Certainly not in maximizing his talent.
Not necessarily a Bad Guy. Just a guy that would take the money but much rather be doing something else.
Just one example. In his rookie season, he would often do interviews with the local sports media. Toney expressed his wish that he be referred to as Yung Joka ... his stage name as Toney was an aspiring rapper.
Brian Daboll moved-on from Toney almost immediately. Andy Reid (and Patrick Mahomes) could not get much out of his tremendous talent; and neither could Kevin Stefanski. That's three quality (diverse) offensive minds.
Kadarius Toney is a Big Stay Away for me.